Correlation
There is a correlation between increasing CO2 (and other greenhouse gases) in the atmosphere and increasing global temperatures. There is a precedent for this type of correlation = For example the Ozone Layer Hole and the Montreal Protocol.
- CO2 Measurement
- Cape Grim (CSIRO)= Increased Carbon Dioxide, Methane and Nitrous Oxide since 1980.
- Mauna Loa (NOAA)= Increased Carbon Dioxide since 1960.
- Temperature
- Temperature Aggergates
- GHCN (Global Historical Climatology Network aggregated instrumental data) = data since 1880, upward trend since 1980
- MET (Meteorological Office United Kingdom) = data since 1850 upward trend since 1970
- NASA aggregation of NOAA, NASA, MET and Japanese Meteorological Office = data since 1880, upward trend since 1970
- Individual Temperature sources
- Satellite data
- UAH (University of Alabama in Huntsville) = data since 1979, upward trend since 1979 and then a cooling dip since 2016
- RSS (Remote Sensing Systems) = data since 1980, upward trend since 1980
- Sea surface
- CRU (University of East Anglia Climate Research Unit) = data since 1979, upward since 1985 and then a cooling dip since 2015
A small but consistent and global increase in global temperature would have a negative effect on human flourishing.
However what's difficult is:
- accurately measuring the severity of consequences
- distinguishing between natural climatic events and anthropomorphic climate events
- creating a predictive model that is both accurate and then provides a warning of danger
Risk
How do we evaluate the likelihood and consequence of an event?
- Historical precedents
- Imagining and modelling the scenarios
. | Insignificant | Minor | Moderate | Major | Critical | Absolute |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rare | - | - | - | Sudden die-back of critical food source | Alien invasion | Sudden black-hole in the solar system |
Unlikely | - | - | - | Global theocracy | Super volcano | Future unforeseen global disaster |
Possible | - | - | Global recession | Solar Storm | Meteorite strike | Malevolent world government |
Likely | - | Major chemical disaster | EMP | Global pandemic | Nuclear War | Own death before Jesus returns |
Almost Certain | Local waste management failure | Local Pollution problems | AI singularity | Loss of species diversity | Climate Change ?? | - |
Definite | Celebrity deaths | - | New wars in global hot spots | - | - | Judgement Day |
Solution
If Climate Change is a serious risk then we need a solution, but one that doesn't remove our collective ability to respond to other serious risks. Our approach to finding and implementing the solution should include the following aspects:
- An attitude of stewardship which desires to encourage human flourishing
- A positive cost-benefit ratio = the greatest mitigation for the littlest cost
- A scaleable approach that benefits human flourishing even if Climate Change turns out not to be a serious risk, but can be escalated dramatically if Climate Change grows in severity and likelihood.
[photograph from unsplash]